Brian

1. “You guys got any milk?” (The Whole Truth - S2 E16)

2. Jack passes the mantle of Protector of the Island to Hurley (The End - S6 E17)

3. Ilana forgives Ben (Dr. Linus - S6 E07)

4. Ben outside the church (The End - S6 E17)

5. “There’s a new sheriff in town, boys.” (The Long Con - S2 E13)

6. Not Penny’s Boat (Through the Looking Glass, Part 2 - S3 E23)

7. Boarding Flight 815 montage (Exodus, Part 2 - S1 E24)

8. Hurley starts the bus (Tricia Tanaka Is Dead - S3 E10)

9. Hurley shares a candy bar with Ben (Cabin Fever - S4 E11)

10. Locke beats on the hatch (Deus Ex Machina - S1 E19)

Melissa

1. Charlie says he knows he’ll die (Through the Looking Glass, Part 2 - S3 E23)

2. Jack vows to kill Locke; Kate shoots Locke (The End - S6 E17)

3. Locke saves Juliet from getting hand cut off (The Lie - S5 E02)

4. Ben tells Juliet she belongs to him; Ben is free and walking with laundry (The Other Woman - S4 E06)

5. Jack catches and spikes football (Par Avion - S3 E12)

6. Hurley starts the bus (Tricia Tanaka Is Dead - S3 E10)

7. Ethan kidnaps Claire (Raised by Another - S1 E10)

8. Rousseau and Alex die (The Shape of Things to Come - S4 E09)

9. Smoke monster kills Jacob’s followers (Because You Left - S6 E01)

10. Ilana forgives Ben (Dr. Linus - S6 E07)